Pick out a fresh, scratch-made cake from our case, or contact us to order a custom cake. Special order cakes, build your own flavors, and extra decorations require one week advance notice. To order a wedding cake or other big event cake, schedule a consultation and check out our Custom Cake Gallery!

Cake Flavors

Signature Cakes

Every day is a good day for cake! These cakes are available daily, year-round.

  • Mandarin Orange – Delicate yellow cake flavored with mandarin oranges; finished with a pineapple non-dairy whipped topping.

  • Marble Fudge – Chocolate and yellow cake swirled together, filled with layers of chocolate fudge; finished with creamy non-dairy whipped topping.

  • Chocolate Lover’s Cake – Chocolate cake layered with French Silk Mousse; finished with Chocolate Ganache Frosting.

We also offer Monthly Specials like Spice Cake, Chocolate Mocha, German Chocolate, and lots more flavors that rotate seasonally.

Visit the bakery to view the selection!

Classic Cakes

A collection of our favorite flavor combinations! Available by special order.

  • German Chocolate – A light chocolate cake finished with homemade coconut-pecan frosting.

  • Carrot – Homemade with fresh carrots, pecans, pineapple and raisins, finished with cream cheese frosting.

  • Banana Torte – Banana cake layered with fresh bananas, vanilla custard, and topped with buttercream or whipped topping. This cake is best when eaten the day of pick up.

  • Lemon Torte – Lemon cake layered with our homemade lemon curd, frosted with non-dairy whipped topping.

  • Strawberry Supreme – Our seasonal farm special! Yellow cake layered with Johnson’s homegrown strawberries and mounds of whipped topping. AVAILABLE ONLY IN JUNE!

Custom Cakes

We'd love to make a special cake for your special occasion. Contact us one week in advance for specialty and build your own cakes.

Wedding Cakes & Large Scale Event Cakes

Have a special event in your future? We'd love to help you celebrate. Schedule a consultation and tasting with a cake designer. You can bring up to four people to try the yummy, frosty goodness. A $25 fee is required, but it will go towards your cake order of $250 or more. We encourage you to print and complete our cake consultation form in advance.

Cupcake Towers & More

The possibilities of sugary love don't end with large scale cakes (although we love them). Our other cake options include: Decorated Cupcakes, Cupcake Tower, Groom’s Cakes, Decorated Sugar Cookies, and Cake Pops.

Scratch-made Frosting

Marilyn's makes two unique buttercream frostings from scratch with real ingredients. Traditional Buttercream is sweet and made with powdered sugar. Swiss Buttercream is smooth, light, and buttery. Both are best enjoyed at room temperature. Sample each to see which you prefer!

Cake Flavors 

  • Banana

  • Carrot

  • Coconut

  • Devil’s Food

  • German Chocolate

  • Lemon

  • Marble

  • Mandarin

  • Red Velvet

  • Yellow

  • White


Frosted Goodness

  • Traditional Buttercream

  • Swiss Buttercream

  • Chocolate Buttercream

  • Coconut Whipped Topping

  • Cream Cheese

  • Fudge Frosting

  • Ganache

  • German Chocolate Frosting

  • Peanut Butter Cream Cheese

  • Pineapple Whipped Topping

  • Salted Caramel Buttercream

  • Strawberry Buttercream

  • Whipped Topping

Favorite Fillings 

  • Any of our frostings

  • Bananas & Cream

  • Chocolate Pudding

  • Coconut Cream

  • French Silk Mousse

  • Lemon

  • Raspberry Jam

  • Strawberry Jam

  • Strawberry Mascarpone Mousse

  • Tiramisu


... Plus seasonal/specialty flavors!