Pies

We use fresh or fresh-frozen fruit that we sweeten and thicken ourselves. Our focus is on local fruit when possible. It is healthier, provides for the local economy, reduces the carbon footprint, and just tastes better! 

At Marilyn’s Bakery, we bake like Grandma did – from scratch. We use palm shortening (trans-fat free) for our crusts, and we never use preservatives. Our Very Berry pie was named "Best Pie East of the Mississippi by Sustainable Table's Pie Across America!

Our pies are available in 6" and 9" sizes. Fruit pies are also available frozen to bake at home. Cream pies are topped with meringue, and we can substitute non-dairy whipped topping upon request. Yes, we have pies for most dietary needs, including vegan, gluten-free, and sugar-free!

Year-round Pie Flavors

Order ahead or come browse the bakery case to see what’s fresh today.

  • apple pie

  • apple crumb pie

  • banana cream pie

  • blueberry pie

  • caramel apple pie

  • cherry pie

  • cherry crumb pie

  • chocolate cream pie

  • chocolate peanut butter pie

  • coconut cream pie

  • French silk pie

  • key lime pie

  • lemon meringue pie

  • peanut butter pie

  • pecan pie

  • strawberry rhubarb pie

  • very berry pie

Chicken Pot Pie

Chicken pot pies are often available in the freezer case at both our Hobart and St. John bakeries.

Seasonal Pies

We bake the following pie flavors during holiday seasons and when fresh local fruit is in season. Check out our seasonal treats page for approximate timing and be sure to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and sign up for email to find out what’s fresh this week!

  • blackberry pie

  • chocolate pecan pie

  • cranberry pecan pie

  • holiday mint pie

  • mint french silk pie

  • peach apricot pie

  • peach pie

  • pumpkin pie

  • red raspberry pie

  • rhubarb pie

  • rhubarb custard pie

  • strawberry whipped pie

  • sweet potato pie

Holiday Pies

We have pies for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter, plus other holiday favorites like dinner rolls, pumpkin cheesecake, pumpkin rolls, nut rolls, bunny cakes, cookies, toffee, and more. Order ahead or come browse the bakery case.

Pie Day & Pi Day

Celebrate National Pie Day with us on January 23rd each year at our St. John Location, and celebrate Pi Day on March 14th with us at both bakery locations with fun activities and giveaways. 

Pie Baking Instructions & Ingredients

See specific instructions and tips for each of our pies.